Sino-Austronesian languages

Sino-Austronesian
(spurious)
Geographic distribution:	East, South and Southeast Asia
Linguistic classification:	proposed language family
Subdivisions:	Sino-Tibetan Austronesian Tai–Kadai
Glottolog:	None

Sino-Austronesian or Sino-Tibetan-Austronesian is a proposed language family suggested by Laurent Sagart in 1990. Using reconstructions of the Old Chinese language, Sagart argued that the Austronesian languages are related to the Sinitic languages phonologically, lexically and morphologically. Sagart later acknowledged that the Sino-Tibetan languages are a valid group and extended his proposal to include the rest of Sino-Tibetan. Additionally, the Tai–Kadai languages were placed internally within the Austronesian family as a sister branch of Malayo-Polynesian. However, peer review has rejected the proposal, finding the comparisons to be spurious.

Classification

• Sino-Austronesian (Sino-Tibetan–Austronesian)
  • Sino-Tibetan
    • Tibeto-Burman
    • Sinitic
  • Austronesian
    • Luilang, Pazeh, Saisiat
    • Pituish
      • Atayalic, Thao, Favorlang, Taokas, Papora, Hoanya
      • Enemish
        • Siraya
        • Walu-Siwaish
          • Tsouic, Paiwan, Rukai, Puyuma, Amis, Bunun
          • Muish
            • Northeastern Formosan (Kavalan, etc.)
            • Tai–Kadai (Daic or Kra–Dai)
            • Malayo-Polynesian

Criticism

Ostapirat (2005) supports the link between Austronesian and Kra–Dai (Sagart built upon Ostapirat's findings), but rejects a link to Sino-Tibetan. He notes that the apparent cognates are rarely found in all branches of Kra–Dai, and almost none are in core vocabulary.

Blust (2014) notes that Sagart circumvents valid use of the comparative method, saying his "device for manufacturing evidence of genetic relationship where none exists is what can be called 'fishing for dregs'", and that basic vocabulary is hardly represented in the comparisons.

Distributions

Distribution of Sino-Tibetan languages  Distribution of Tai–Kadai languages  Distribution of Austroasiatic languages  Distribution of Hmong–Mien languages  Distribution of Formosan languages  Distribution of Formosan languages – Blust (1999)  Distribution of Formosan languages – Greenhill, Blust & Gray (2008)  Distribution of Austronesian languages

See also

• Classification schemes for Southeast Asian languages
  • Austric languages
  • Austro-Tai languages
• Dené–Caucasian languages
• Austronesian languages
• Sino-Tibetan languages
  • Old Chinese language
  • Tibeto-Burman languages
• Haplogroup O (Y-DNA)
• Languages of China

References

• Sagart, Laurent 2005. "Sino-Tibetan–Austronesian: an updated and improved argument." In Laurent Sagart, Roger Blench & Alicia Sanchez-Mazas, eds. The Peopling of East Asia: Putting Together Archaeology, Linguistics and Genetics. London: Routledge Curzon, pp. 161–176.
• Sagart, Laurent. 2004. The higher phylogeny of Austronesian and the position of Tai–Kadai. Oceanic Linguistics 43:411–440.
• Sagart, Laurent. 1994. Proto-Austronesian and the Old Chinese evidence for Sino-Austronesian. Oceanic Linguistics 33:271–308.
• Sagart, Laurent. 1990. Chinese and Austronesian are genetically related. Paper presented at the 23rd International Conference on Sino-Tibetan Languages and Linguistics, October 1990, Arlington, Texas.
• Starosta, Stanley. 2005. "Proto-east Asian and the origin and dispersal of the languages of East and Southeast Asia and the Pacific." In Laurent Sagart, Roger Blench & Alicia Sanchez-Mazas, eds. The Peopling of East Asia: Putting Together Archaeology, Linguistics and Genetics. London: Routledge Curzon, pp. 182–197.

External links

• Laurent Sagart's list of Old Chinese words at the Austronesian Basic Vocabulary Database